Nutella Stuffed Cake Mix Cookies

Nutella Stuffed Cake Mix Cookies

Super-soft Cookies Stuffed with Nutella!

Can you tell I am a fan of Nutella?

Seriously, when I buy a jar I have to defend it with my life.

Nutella stuffed cake mix cookies

Just let me be alone with the Nutella jar!

Anyway, I guess it’s a good thing the kids are around because I might be just a wee bit heavier if they weren’t…;0)

Nutella Stuffed Cookies are Made from a Cake Mix

nutella cookies recipe

Last year I discovered cake mix cookies.

That was one of the Top 50 Best Days of My Life.

Pitiful, I know, but hey — my days are always brighter when I find short-cuts.

Cake Mix Makes These Nutella Cookies Super Easy to Make!

Thanks to the cake mix hack, I can surprised my kids with cookies any day of the week!

I just stir a box of cake mix together and roll out some cookie dough, bake and the kids are chowing down on some semi-homemade cookies.

Really. It’s that easy.

nutella cookie recipe

Nutella Stuffed Cookies are Super Soft

Now these cake mix cookies are a little bit trickier than some of our other cookie recipes.

It took me a little while to get the stuffed thing going on.

I almost thought my pics would end up being one of those “nailed it” photos of stuffed cookies.

But, after several failed attempts, I finally got my cookies cooperating with me.

stuffed cookies recipe

I’m actually glad I messed up the first batch because then I knew what mistakes to tell my readers to avoid.

I don’t want you trying my recipe and then saying “Nailed it” on Pinterest.

I really want you to like my recipes and succeed at this cooking and baking thing!

So, before you get rolling out the dough, here are some tips for making stuffed cookies.

Tips for Making Nutella Stuffed Cookies

Refrigerate your cookie dough.

No matter what recipe you are using, and no matter what that person says, refrigerate your dough before assembling a stuffed cookie.

You need a firm cookie dough to get these cookies to cooperate during the stuffing process.

Take your time making the Nutella stuffed cookies.

Don’t bake these when you’re in a rush.

Make cake mix cookies, yes, but not stuffed ones.

It takes a little bit more patience and time.

Keep your hands dry during the baking process.

Silly me!

I was washing my hands off after a few cookies and heading right back to the dough, only to have those cookies slip around and not obey my orders.

So, take it from me — work with dry hands.

Flatten the Nutella cookies.

Some recipes say roll into balls and then form.

It didn’t work for me.

I rolled into balls and then flattened.

After the cookie was flat, I was able to successfully assemble a stuffed cookie.

Don’t overbake the cookies.

These cookies will look underbaked when they are perfectly baked.

Don’t go past the ten-minute mark!

OK, now you’re ready to conquer this recipe!

You won’t be sorry you did!

This is my hubby’s fave cookie recipe so far, and he is a difficult, taste-testing judge.

So get ready to bake some irresistibly, delicious cookies!

Nutella Stuffed Cookies

Ingredients:

1 box vanilla cake mix
2 large eggs
1/3 cup oil
1/2 teaspoon vanilla
1/2 cup Nutella

Directions:

Mix all ingredients together, except the Nutella.

Once thoroughly combined, chill the dough for 30 minutes in refrigerator.

Chill the Nutella for 30 minutes as well.

Once the Nutella and cookie dough are both chilled, preheat oven to 400 degrees Fahrenheit.

Next, roll the cookie dough into 1 teaspoon-sized balls and then flatten.

Carefully drop about 1/2 heaping teaspoon of Nutella on top of flattened cookie.

Then, place another rolled and flattened cookie on top of the Nutella and seal all edges.

The cookie will be tall but will flatten when baking.

Repeat for each cookie.

Bake on parchment-lined cookie sheet for 8 minutes.

Remove and let cool for 15 minutes. Enjoy!

Yields: 16 stuffed cookies.

If you loved that inspiration, we're sure you'll love these too!

5 thoughts on “Nutella Stuffed Cake Mix Cookies”

  1. I have a gas stove and found 400 degrees to be too high and the bottom of the cookies started to burn before the tops were cooked. I adjusted down to 350 and they came out perfect.

  2. Pingback: Over 50 Cake Mix Cookie Recipes! – 3 Boys and a Dog

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Close

Get into the Season!

In our handy book, you'll find 25 unique and simple ideas to celebrate Christmas with your family. Use code CHRISTMAS25 at checkout to get $4 off (44% off)! Get yours now!

25 Days of Christmas: A Family
No, thanks.